Desserts

"Our pledge to you is simple - to provide outstanding service and value with great American food!"

Blueberry Bread Pudding

Blueberry Bread Pudding


 

An Old Fashioned, delicious comfort dessert! Buttery croissants steeped in vanilla custard, stuffed with fresh blueberries and chocolate chips. Served with vanilla anglaise.

$ 5.99

<-- back to menu

Chocolate Molten Cake

Chocolate Molten Cake


 

Warm chocolate cake with a creamy, molten center served with a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream on top. We add chocolate sauce and berries to finish this delicious dessert.

$ 5.99

<-- back to menu

Cinnamon Peach Cobbler

Cinnamon Peach Cobbler


 

Sweet Georgia Peaches cooked with cinnamon, nutmeg and a hint of vanilla, topped with stuessal and baked to a golden brown.

$ 5.99

<-- back to menu

New York Cheesecake

New York Cheesecake


 

Traditional New York Style Cheesecake served with fresh berries, whipped cream and vanilla anglaise.

$ 5.99

<-- back to menu

Our menu offers a wide variety of unique and fresh appetizers, entrees, desserts and more. We also offer one of the best beer and wine selections in downtown Columbus including our very own O'Tooles Microbrew!

view | menu

Conveniently located in downtown Columbus Ohio, Michael O'Tooles is a great place to start your evening with dinner or drinks and explore some of these nearby attractions including sports arenas, night clubs and hotels.

hotels | theaters | other

Send us photographs taken of you and your friends at Michael O'Toole's and we will post them on our web site  - helping your memories become a part of our memories.

view all | submit your own