Bacon Cheeseburger

Topped with smoked apple wood bacon, choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion and house made garlic mayonnaise.

All of Our Burgers are Cooked to Order.

$ 9.99

<-- back to menu

Buffalo Chicken Sandwhich

Grilled chicken breast tossed in spicy buffalo sauce, topped with lettuce, tomato and blue cheese dressing. Served with Boardwalk French Fries or Kettle Chips.

$ 8.99

<-- back to menu

Chicken Salad BLT

Our creamy chicken salad with crisp apple wood smoked bacon, lettuce and tomato served on a fresh baked croissant. Served with Boardwalk French Fries or Kettle Chips.

$ 9.99

<-- back to menu

Classic Meatloaf Sandwhich

Wrapped with smoked bacon, topped with pepper jack cheese and tangy BBQ sauce.

$ 9.99

<-- back to menu

Coal Miners Burger

Stacked with apple wood smoked bacon, colossal onion rings,cheddar cheese and smothered with BBQ sauce. Served with Boardwalk French Fries or Kettle Chips.

All of Our Burgers are Cooked to Order.

$ 9.99

<-- back to menu

Fisherman's Sandwhich

Battered cold water deep fried fish with lettuce, tomato and southern remoulade sauce. Served with Boardwalk French Fries or Kettle Chips.

$ 11.99

<-- back to menu

Flame Broiled Veggie Burger

Black bean burger topped with lettuce, tomato, avocado and house made garlic mayonnaise served on our house brioche bun.

Served with Boardwalk French Fries or Kettle Chips.

$ 8.99

<-- back to menu

German Bologna Sandwhich

This “Thick Cut” bologna sandwich is the best south of Waldo, served with sliced dill pickle, red onion and spicy mustard. Served with Boardwalk French Fries or Kettle Chips.

$ 8.99

<-- back to menu

Michael O'Tooles Burger

With lettuce, tomato, red onion and house made garlic mayonnaise. Served with Boardwalk French Fries or Kettle Chips.

All of Our Burgers are Cooked to Order.

$ 8.99

<-- back to menu

Michael's Combo

Pick any half sandwich and your choice of soup or salad.

Small Michael's House Salad

New England Clam Chowder, Cheffery's Daily Soup

1/2 Stacked High Classic Reuben,  1/2 O'Toole's Classic Club, 1/2 Chicken Salad BLT

$ 8.99

<-- back to menu

Mushroom & Swiss Burger

A blend of sautéed mushrooms, Swiss cheese and a hint of truffle oil.  Topped with fresh lettuce, tomato and onion.

$ 9.99

<-- back to menu

O'Tooles Classic Club

Sliced turkey, ham, apple wood smoked bacon, swiss and cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise (house made garlic mayonnaise available). Served with Boardwalk French Fries or Kettle Chips.

$ 9.99

<-- back to menu

Prime Rib French Dip

O’Toole’s own Prime Rib, shaved thin and stacked high with onion, mushrooms, provolone cheese, horseradish cream sauce and au jus. Served with Boardwalk French Fries or Kettle Chips.

$ 12.99

<-- back to menu

Sausage Hoagie

Sweet Italian sausage smothered with peppers and onions.  Served on a toasted hoagie roll.

$ 9.99

<-- back to menu

Stacked High Classic Reuben

Piled high with half pound of corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss cheese, 1000 island dressing on grilled marble rye. Served with Boardwalk French Fries or Kettle Chips.

$ 10.99

<-- back to menu